Re: [PATCH v2 1/1] ARM: signal: sigreturn_codes should be endian neutral to work in BE8

[adding Nico to this thread]

Nico, could you please look at Dave's comment inline about sigreturn_codes size. It was long time ago, but maybe you can recall why sigreturn_codes size is 7 words, but not 6? It was set by your fcca538b83f2984095f15f0f90f6c7686e3a32d4 ([ARM] 3270/1: ARM EABI: fix sigreturn and rt_sigreturn) commit

Dave, thank you, good comments! I think I can accommodate most of them. Please see few issues inline.

On 15 August 2013 03:57, Dave Martin Dave.Martin@arm.com wrote:

On Wed, Aug 14, 2013 at 12:08:54AM -0700, Victor Kamensky wrote:

...

In case of BE8 kernel data is in BE order whereas code stays in LE order. Move sigreturn_codes to separate .S file and use proper assembler mnemonics for these code snippets. In this case compiler will take care of proper instructions byteswaps for BE8 case. Change assumes that sufficiently Thumb-capable tools are used to build kernel.

Problem was discovered during ltp testing of BE system: all rt_sig* tests failed. Tested against the same tests in both BE and LE modes.

This looks sensible to me, but I have a few comments -- see below.

Cheers ---Dave

...

Signed-off-by: Victor Kamensky victor.kamensky@linaro.org

arch/arm/kernel/Makefile | 3 +- arch/arm/kernel/signal.c | 29 +++--------------- arch/arm/kernel/sigreturn_codes.S | 64 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 3 files changed, 70 insertions(+), 26 deletions(-) create mode 100644 arch/arm/kernel/sigreturn_codes.S

diff --git a/arch/arm/kernel/Makefile b/arch/arm/kernel/Makefile index 86d10dd..0722155 100644 --- a/arch/arm/kernel/Makefile +++ b/arch/arm/kernel/Makefile @@ -17,7 +17,8 @@ CFLAGS_REMOVE_return_address.o = -pg

obj-y := elf.o entry-common.o irq.o opcodes.o \ process.o ptrace.o return_address.o \

•            setup.o signal.o stacktrace.o sys_arm.o time.o traps.o
  

•            setup.o signal.o sigreturn_codes.o \
  

•            stacktrace.o sys_arm.o time.o traps.o
  
  

obj-$(CONFIG_ATAGS) += atags_parse.o obj-$(CONFIG_ATAGS_PROC) += atags_proc.o diff --git a/arch/arm/kernel/signal.c b/arch/arm/kernel/signal.c index ab33042..cdcbf04 100644 --- a/arch/arm/kernel/signal.c +++ b/arch/arm/kernel/signal.c @@ -21,29 +21,8 @@ #include <asm/unistd.h> #include <asm/vfp.h>

-/*

• • For ARM syscalls, we encode the syscall number into the instruction.
• */

-#define SWI_SYS_SIGRETURN (0xef000000|(__NR_sigreturn)|(__NR_OABI_SYSCALL_BASE)) -#define SWI_SYS_RT_SIGRETURN (0xef000000|(__NR_rt_sigreturn)|(__NR_OABI_SYSCALL_BASE))

-/*

• • With EABI, the syscall number has to be loaded into r7.
• */

-#define MOV_R7_NR_SIGRETURN (0xe3a07000 | (__NR_sigreturn - __NR_SYSCALL_BASE)) -#define MOV_R7_NR_RT_SIGRETURN (0xe3a07000 | (__NR_rt_sigreturn - __NR_SYSCALL_BASE))

-/*

• • For Thumb syscalls, we pass the syscall number via r7. We therefore
• • need two 16-bit instructions.
• */

-#define SWI_THUMB_SIGRETURN (0xdf00 << 16 | 0x2700 | (__NR_sigreturn - __NR_SYSCALL_BASE)) -#define SWI_THUMB_RT_SIGRETURN (0xdf00 << 16 | 0x2700 | (__NR_rt_sigreturn - __NR_SYSCALL_BASE))

-static const unsigned long sigreturn_codes[7] = {

• MOV_R7_NR_SIGRETURN,    SWI_SYS_SIGRETURN,    SWI_THUMB_SIGRETURN,
  

• MOV_R7_NR_RT_SIGRETURN, SWI_SYS_RT_SIGRETURN, SWI_THUMB_RT_SIGRETURN,
  

-}; +extern const unsigned long sigreturn_codes[];

Could be [_NR_SIGRETURN_CODES] -- see below.

Then you can revert to using sizeof(sigreturn_codes), as previously.

...

+extern const int sigreturn_codes_size;

Might go away too

...

static unsigned long signal_return_offset;

@@ -639,10 +618,10 @@ struct page *get_signal_page(void) * Copy signal return handlers into the vector page, and * set sigreturn to be a pointer to these. */

• memcpy(addr + offset, sigreturn_codes, sizeof(sigreturn_codes));
  

• memcpy(addr + offset, sigreturn_codes, sigreturn_codes_size);
  
  ptr = (unsigned long)addr + offset;
  

• flush_icache_range(ptr, ptr + sizeof(sigreturn_codes));
  

• flush_icache_range(ptr, ptr + sigreturn_codes_size);
  
  return page;
  

} diff --git a/arch/arm/kernel/sigreturn_codes.S b/arch/arm/kernel/sigreturn_codes.S new file mode 100644 index 0000000..3ac1540 --- /dev/null +++ b/arch/arm/kernel/sigreturn_codes.S @@ -0,0 +1,64 @@ +/*

• • sigreturn_codes.S - code sinpets for sigreturn syscalls
• • Created by: Victor Kamensky, 2013-08-13
• • Copyright: (C) 2013 Linaro Limited
• • This program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify
• • it under the terms of the GNU General Public License version 2 as
• • published by the Free Software Foundation.
• • This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
• • but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
• • MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the
• • GNU General Public License for more details.
• */

+#include <asm/unistd.h>

+/*

• • For ARM syscalls, we encode the syscall number into the instruction.
• • With EABI, the syscall number has to be loaded into r7. As result
• • ARM syscall sequence snippet will have move and svc in .arm encoding
• • For Thumb syscalls, we pass the syscall number via r7. We therefore
• • need two 16-bit instructions in .thumb encoding
• */

• .text
  

Maybe this should be in .rodata instead. We only copy the instructions from here... if we ever execute them here, something has gone wrong somewhere.

This won't affect link-time swabbing.

...

• .global sigreturn_codes
  

• .type   sigreturn_codes, #object
  

+sigreturn_codes:

The above 3 lines can be replaced with ENTRY()...ENDPROC().

(.type / ENDPROC() isn't really required here, though. I would suggest omitting them, since although we assemble this as code, we really access it as data)

...

• /* ARM sigreturn syscall code snippet */
  

• .arm
  

.arm can insert padding for alignment purposes. To be on the safe side, I suggest moving the first .arm just before the sigreturn_codes label. This will avoid strange surprises if extra code is inserted into this file later.

...

• mov     r7, #(__NR_sigreturn - __NR_SYSCALL_BASE)
  

• svc     #(__NR_sigreturn)|(__NR_OABI_SYSCALL_BASE)
  

The "svc" mnemonic was invented for ARMv6.

Since all platforms rely on this code, including v4/v5, we should use the old "swi" mnemonic throughout this file instead.

...

• /* Thumb sigreturn syscall code snippet */
  

• .thumb
  

We should add a comment warning the reader that these instructions are not executed in-place, and are expected to have a precise, fixed layout.

...

• movs    r7, #(__NR_sigreturn - __NR_SYSCALL_BASE)
  

• svc     #0
  

• /* ARM sigreturn_rt syscall code snippet */
  

• .arm
  

• mov     r7, #(__NR_rt_sigreturn - __NR_SYSCALL_BASE)
  

• svc     #(__NR_rt_sigreturn)|(__NR_OABI_SYSCALL_BASE)
  

• /* Thumb sigreturn_rt syscall code snippet */
  

• .thumb
  

• movs    r7, #(__NR_rt_sigreturn - __NR_SYSCALL_BASE)
  

• svc     #0
  

• .arm
  

• .space  4
  

Nico, do you know what the spare word at the end of this array was for? Is it ABI, or just an accidental off-by-one?

It was introduced in commit fcca538b83f2984095f15f0f90f6c7686e3a32d4 ([ARM] 3270/1: ARM EABI: fix sigreturn and rt_sigreturn), but I can't see clearly why it's needed.

...

+__sigreturn_codes_end:

• .size   sigreturn_codes, . - sigreturn_codes
  

• .section .rodata
  

• .global sigreturn_codes_size
  

• .type   sigreturn_codes_size, #object
  

• .size   sigreturn_codes_size, 4
  

+sigreturn_codes_size:

• .long __sigreturn_codes_end - sigreturn_codes
  

The correct size is statically fixed by hard-coded assumptions in signal.c -- we don't want to hide mis-edits by pretending to adapt to size changes.

So instead of the above lines you could do something like this:

arch/arm/include/asm/signal.h: #define _NR_SIGRETURN_CODES 7 /* or mabye 6? */ #define _SIGRETURN_CODES_SIZE (4 * _NR_SIGRETURN_CODES)

Note since arch/arm/include/asm/signal.h is part of public API, adding above defines in the file would require '#ifdef __KERNEL__' guards. Also since the file was not included in .S file before '#ifndef __ASSEMBLY__' statements will have to be added.

sigreturn_codes.S: #include <asm/signal.h>

/* ... */ svc #0

    .if     . - sigreturn_codes != _SIGRETURN_CODES_SIZE
    .error  "Incorrect size for sigreturn_codes"
    .endif

Nice trick. I see few examples of it in existing code. Unfortunately it does not work for me - it seems to me that the reason is an assembler bug. It looks like when movs mnemonics is used in thumb mode with 'unified' syntax it causes gas to complain that size of address expression over code is not constant. Here is tiny example that illustrates the issue:

[kamensky@kamensky-w530 linux-linaro-tracking-be]$ cat /home/kamensky/tmp/codesize.S .syntax unified

test: .thumb /* * presence of movs instruction in thumb mode causes * non-constant expression in which 'test' and '.' * participate */ movs r7, #153 swi #0

.if (. - test) != 4 .error "Incorrect size" .endif

[kamensky@kamensky-w530 linux-linaro-tracking-be]$ arm-linux-gnueabihf-as -o codesize.o /home/kamensky/tmp/codesize.S /home/kamensky/tmp/codesize.S: Assembler messages: /home/kamensky/tmp/codesize.S:13: Error: non-constant expression in ".if" statement [kamensky@kamensky-w530 linux-linaro-tracking-be]$ arm-linux-gnueabihf-as --version GNU assembler (crosstool-NG linaro-1.13.1-4.7-2013.01-20130125 - Linaro GCC 2013.01) 2.22

Or am I missing something here?

I think in this situation since this code has auxiliary/defensive meaning, maybe we can drop it and rely on comment that would request size of snippet in assembler to match size of array in extern statement.

Also in this case if we cannot use _SIGRETURN_CODES_SIZE in .S file, I don't think there is a need to modify arch/arm/include/asm/signal.h. These defines may be placed directly into arch/arm/kernel/signal.c, or even omitted with sigreturn_codes using size directly as it is now.

Thanks, Victor

Cheers ---Dave